lãñÔóÂÜÀ­³ó

    1. <form id=vvPdBrbUA><nobr id=vvPdBrbUA></nobr></form>
      <address id=vvPdBrbUA><nobr id=vvPdBrbUA><nobr id=vvPdBrbUA></nobr></nobr></address>

      Jackdaws love my big sphinx of quartz - Book Review: Empire of the Summer Moon [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
      Scott

      [ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
      [ archive | journal archive ]

      Book Review: Empire of the Summer Moon [Nov. 13th, 2012|01:45 am]
      Previous Entry Add to Memories Share Next Entry
      [Tags|, ]
      [Current Location |Birmingham, AL]

      History is a lot like xkcd: I expected it to be sad, I expected it to be wonderful, but I never expected it to be so big.

      As a child, history comes so neatly packaged. First there was Egypt and Babylon. Then there was Greece. Then Rome. Then some Middle Ages and also the Rise of Islam. Then Columbus and Magellan. Then the Colonial Period, the Revolution, some stuff happens, the Civil War, World Wars One and Two, the Cold War, The Struggle For Civil Rights, and the present. China might have been involved at some point too.

      And it's all so interesting that you don't realize until later that none of it makes sense. How come Egypt was like the only game in town for a thousand years and then suddenly stopped being relevant? The Goths sacked Rome? Who the heck were the Goths, where did they come from before sacking Rome, and what happened to them afterwards? How exactly did a prophet from a tiny desert city manage to conquer like six big empires in half a century? Where was the entire rest of the vast and fertile American continent when the Aztecs and the Incas were building their civilizations? Did Russia just suddenly appear one day out of the aether?

      The first time I got to read a better class of history book was Larry Gonick's Cartoon History of the Universe. I got it as a kid, probably figuring that as a cartoon it would be a light-hearted and funny treatment of history along the same lines as the ones I'd already read. I was absolutely wrong. Not only did it address all the background factors my school books had glossed over as "for economic reasons" or "because of internal struggle", but it expanded the scale by an order of magnitude.

      Phoenicia. Armenia. Lombardy. Almoravids. The Kara-Khitan Khanate and the Black and White Sheep Turkmen. The Ghana Empire and Songhai. The Safavids, Vijayanagara. People and places I'd never heard of who were a big deal in their time.

      And not only that. The Yellow Turban Rebellion killed more people than Vietnam; the White Lotus Rebellion killed as many people as World War One. The largest city in the world between the fall of Rome and the Industrial Revolution was Angkor, capital of the Khmer Empire in Cambodia. Ten percent of the Roman population was Jewish, and after the Diaspora the Jews revolted and massacred hundreds of thousands of Romans before being brought under control. There are giant pyramids in Missouri constructed by a Native American tribe no white man ever met who built cities larger than the great European capitals of the time. The Prime Minister of France asked to join Great Britain in the 1950s, but the British rejected his offer; Syria and Egypt did merge in the 1950s but broke apart a few years later.

      And so on in that vein. The point is, I have grown used to unexpected history.

      Still, I was surprised to learn that there had been an Native American empire larger in size than the Aztecs who soundly defeated the conquistadors, fought off the US Army for thirty years, and stayed independent until the 1870s right in the middle of the United States, and that I had never heard of them before.

      Empire of the Summer Moon was a book about the Comanche Indians. They were not very advanced by "civilized" standards. They didn't build cities, farm crops, centralize government, or have any form of writing. The book argues, hard as it is to believe, that they didn't really even have any art or even a religion. They just rode around on horses hunting buffalo and starting wars. But they were really, really good at it. By the 1800s they had defeated virtually every other Indian tribe in the central United States and extended into modern Texas, Oklahoma, New Mexico, Arizona, Colorado, and Kansas, with their territory bordered by a ring of "vassal" tribes paying them tribute and functioning as a single economic unit.

      In the 1600s and 1700s, the Spanish tried to expand northward from Mexico. They lost some horses, the horses started running wild over the Great Plains, the Comanches captured them and learned horsemanship, and then became so good at it that they actually pushed the Spanish back until finally the Spanish government gave up and promised them lucrative peace terms to leave them alone.

      When Mexico took over from Spain and tried to colonize Texas, the Comanches beat them so soundly that they decided to get some "help" by inviting Anglo-Americans to come in and colonize, leading to the Texas revolt, the Mexican War, and so on. Through the first thirty years or so of American Texas, American control only extended through the eastern half of the state, with the western half being totally Comanche and almost totally unexplored. The border was so feared that places like Fort Worth, Texas were originally a line of actual forts intended to protect the Texans from Comanche raids.

      These raids were probably the most disturbing part of the book. On the one hand, okay, the white people were trying to steal the Comanches' land and they had every right to be angry. On the other hand, the way the Comanches expressed that anger was to occasionally ride in, find a white village or farm or homestead, surround it, and then spend hours or days torturing everyone they found there in the most horrific possible ways before killing the men and enslaving the women and children. Sometimes people were scalped alive. The women would usually be gang-raped dozens of times, and then enslaved, carried off to Comanche territory, and gang-raped some more. Children were forced to watch as their parents were raped and tortured and killed, or vice versa.

      Their favorite pastime was to find a remote farm somewhere, ride in dressed in full war gear, communicate some version of "Oh, hi, I know what this looks like but actually we're just stopping by, mind giving us a bite to eat?", enjoying a lavish feast put on by extremely nervous settlers, and then saying "Very good, in exchange for this feast we give you a five minute head start", then giving them five minutes to run away before riding them down and torture-killing the entire family in the manner described earlier.

      On the other hand, the Comanches fit the classic pattern of hunter-gatherer civilizations of simultaneously being really mean to people outside the tribe while showing deep and heartfelt kindness to everyone within. We know this because sometimes if there were very young children, and the Comanches were feeling a bit low on headcount, they would capture the children and adopt them as full Comanches (after torture-killing the parents, of course) and some of these children would later grow up to write English-language books about their experience. But this practice definitely led to some awkward situations, and the book centers around one of them: the last great chief of the Comanches, Quanah, was half-white, the son of a Comanche chief and a Texan woman who had been captured when she was nine years old.

      So there was a bit of traffic back and forth between America and Comancheria in the 19th century. White people being captured and raised by Comanches. The captives being recaptured years later and taken back into normal white society. Indians being defeated and settled on reservations and taught to adopt white lifestyles. And throughout the book's description of these events, there was one constant:

      All of the white people who joined Indian tribes loved it and refused to go back to white civilization. All the Indians who joined white civilization hated it and did everything they could to go back to their previous tribal lives.

      There was much to like about tribal life. The men had no jobs except to occasionally hunt some buffalo and if they felt courageous to go to war. The women did have jobs like cooking and preparing buffalo, but they still seemed to be getting off easy compared to the white pioneer women or, for that matter, women today. The whole culture was nomadic, basically riding horses wherever they wanted through the vast open plains without any property or buildings or walls. And everyone was amazingly good at what they did; the Comanche men were probably the best archers and horsemen in the history of history, and even women and children had wilderness survival and tracking skills that put even the best white frontiersmen to shame. It sounds like a life of leisure, strong traditions, excellence, and enjoyment of nature, and it doesn't surprise me that people liked it better than the awful white frontier life of backbreaking farming and endless religious sermons.

      And the phenomenon of whites preferring the Indian lifestyle wasn't just limited to the Comanches of the 19th century. A paper by the Omohundro Institute of Early American History and Culture (I wonder if they're related to Steve) notes that:
      "By the close of the colonial period, very few if any Indians had been transformed into civilized Englishmen. Most of the Indians who were educated by the English - some contemporaries thought all of them - returned to Indian society at the first opportunity to resume their Indian identities. Ont he other hand, large numbers of Englishmen had chosen to become Indians - by running away from colonial society to join Indian society, by not trying to escape after being captured, or by electing to remain with their Indian captors when treaties of peace periodically afforded them the opportunity to return home."

      It then goes on to quote no less a figure than Benjamin Franklin, who had independently noticed the same phenomenon:
      "When an Indian Child has been brought up among us, taught our language, and habituated to our Customs, yet if he goes to see his relations and makes one Indian Ramble with them, there is no perswading him ever to return. But when white persons of either sex have been taken prisoner young by the Indians, and lived a while with them, tho' ransomed by their Friends, and treated with all imaginable tenderness to prevail with them to stay among the English, yet in a Short time they become disgusted with our manner of life, and the care and pains that are necessary to support it, and take the first good Opportunity of escaping again into the Woods, from whence there is no reclaiming them."

      Now I know that idealizing the "noble savage" is a well-known and obvious failure mode. But I was struck by this and by the descriptions of white-Comanche interactions in the book. Whites who met Comanches would almost universally rave about how imposing and noble and healthy and self-collected and alive they seemed; there aren't too many records of what the Comanches thought of white people, but the few there are suggest they basically viewed us as pathetic and stunted and defective.

      I remember when I was younger reading one of Ayn Rand's philosophy essay books. And she was talking about New Age return-to-nature aesthetic, and she commented on how ironic it was to see people who could build skyscrapers and fly to the moon venerating people who squatted in the mud and lived in squalid huts as their superiors. I remember being profoundly impressed by it at the time and considering it deep wisdom.

      But now I think about it further and I realize that civilizations aren't people. We are not "people who can build skyscrapers and fly to the moon" - even if someone is the rare engineer who designs skyscrapers for a living, she might not have the slighest idea how to actually go about pouring concrete. And people who have actually met these cultures that live in huts in the mud have almost universally - because this isn't nearly the first time I've heard this - had an incredible respect for them as human beings even as they're disgusted by the primitiveness of their civilization.

      And at the same time, I'm continuing to plod through my book review of Last Superstition and this Aristotelian idea of creatures living in accordance with their nature and creatures acting in unnatural ways and ending up morally defective. Feser keeps returning to his example of a defective squirrel that eats only toothpaste and doesn't want scurry around for acorns with the rest of them, and this has a suitably pathetic feel to it to be valuable.

      I don't believe that there's some kind of objective, ontologically basic reality to this sort of "goodness by living properly in accordance with your nature", but it's hard not to notice that at least in some contigent, non-fundamental way, a squirrel that lived entirely off of toothpaste is pretty pathetic and not operating off of proper squirrel design specs.

      And whenever these virtue ethicists try to think about the nature of humans, they come up with some kind of boring, exactly-what-they-were-doing-already idea of "Well, be a Christian and definitely don't have gay sex, and you should be fine." But Empire of the Summer Moon certainly made it sound - and I realize authors can be pretty good at pushing their viewpoint, but this didn't look deliberate and it was amply supported by quotes from the time - it certainly made it sound like the god-fearing non-gay-sex-having Texans were the toothpaste-eating squirrels and the Comanches were the ones who were dignified and wild and free and living "the good life" in the most Aristotelian sense of the term.

      I have long wondered whether civilization was a mistake. If it was, it is not an easy mistake to avoid. The stubborn persistence of the Comanches aside, once civilized people with technology and professional armies start competing with less civilized people, the results are always going to be lopsided in civilization's favor. We might be at the bottom of a prisoner's dilemma, the descendants of people who defected from a happy equilibrium of hunting and gathering in order to gain a slight numerical and military advantage over their foes, only to end up with everyone large, well-armed, and miserable.

      This is another reason I've always found some modern political philosophies so barren. There's no such thing as society and everyone has free choice over what kind of lifestyle they want? Tell that to the descendants of the Comanches. One of the most heartbreaking stories in the book follows a Comanche band after they'd been on the reservation a while. They protest they want to leave the reservation and go back to traditional life, and eventually the government relaxes and says to try it. They leave the reservation, and...nothing. Their sacred sites have all been bought by cattle ranchers. The wide open plains the once roamed are now dotted with barbed wire and villages. The buffalo they once hunted are now almost extinct. They slink back onto the reservation in despair and stay there until they die.

      One of my hopes for the future is that someone figures out how to combine the aspects of hunter-gatherer life that seem so important for proper human development with some of the advances we've had since then, like medicine and technology and science and not torture-killing people and having some idea what's going on. Barring something unexpected like the Change, I admit this is probably going to have to wait for post-singularity. Right now there's no way out of civilization but through it.

      But getting back to the book. The Comanches resisted the white settlers effectively for about thirty years, mostly because of their greater knowledge of and adaptedness to the Plains environment. It didn't hurt that until about the Civil War, the Comanches' bows-and-arrows were actually better technology than the settlers' guns, since the latter were really difficult to reload and by the time a settler had finished he was usually already shot through with arrows. It got so bad that during the Civil War, the frontier actually was pushed back hundreds of miles and white people had to evacuate several hundred miles worth of Texas. After the Civil War, the US government had lots of soldiers it didn't really know what to do with and decided to turn them on the Comanche "problem".

      One area where the book excelled was in describing the "treaties" the US government would sign with the Indians. I'd always known that the US government had a shameful record of constantly breaking these treaties whenever it saw the least advantage of doing so. I hadn't been aware that the Indians did pretty much the same thing. The treaties were pretty much a farce on both sides: usually the Indian "chief" who signed them was just some local war leader with a really big eagle-feather headdress whom the clueless whites assumed must be "in charge" of the Indian tribe because obviously every group of people must have a centralized government with exactly one person at the head.

      The treaties worked out pretty well for both sides, in a sense. The white politicians would trumpet the achievement of solving the constant struggle with the Indians. The "chief" would go back to his village with a lot of manufactured goods the Americans had given him as bribes/"rewards" for being such a good negotiating partner. It was a win-win situation, unless you actually cared about peace or a just an equitable outcome, in which case it was a disaster.

      The book admitted it wasn't always clear which was the chicken and which was the egg here. Did the Comanches ignore the treaties because they knew that the whites would break them anyway? It pointed out that they did stick pretty exactly to the letter of their peace treaty with the Spanish for several centuries. But overall it seemed like a classic case of politics going stupid on both sides.

      And about politics...I don't know what the Bureau of Indian Affairs is like today, but back in the days when there were actual not-on-reservation Indians, it was the archetype of every corrupt and villainous group of scheming bureaucrats you've ever heard about. Their modus operandi was to find some Indians who were in a conflict with the US, promise them lots of gifts and food if they would give up their land and move to a reservation, laugh hysterically when the Indians agreed, and then pocket the money the government gave them to buy gifts and food and let the Indians starve to death. At one point it got so bad that the government decided to fire all the Indian Affairs people and replace them with Quakers, on the grounds that Quakers seemed trustworthy, but the Quakers had no idea what was going on and were totally pacifist which just made the whole situation worse.

      And the Bureau of Indian Affairs was an equal opportunity thing-screwer-upper. Not only were they horribly unfair to the Indians, but they caused the deaths of a lot of white settlers as well. Part of the government treaty with the Indians said that the government wouldn't send the army onto Indian reservations and kill Indians there, because obviously that defeated the whole point of an Indian reservation. This was probably a good policy with peaceful friendly Indians like the Creek, but when the Comanche heard about it, several Comanche bands "surrendered" and agreed to go on reservations, then used them as a base for their raids, assuming (correctly!) that once they reached their reservation the army couldn't do anything about it. This went on for like a decade with dozens of white people being killed in these raids, and the Bureau of Indian Affairs just sort of said "Sheesh, we got them to go on reservations and you guys are still complaining? We're just going to sit here and do nothing."

      So the history of white-Comanche relations was basically one long tragedy in which both sides competed to see who could be a bigger piece of crap to the other, with the whites eventually winning (we usually do in these kinds of things).

      But the highlight, and the only part that wasn't totally depressing, was the story of Quanah, the half-white last chief of the Comanches. He tried to organize the Comanches into a glorious last stand, and he did pretty well for himself, but when it became obvious it wasn't working he surrendered and went to the reservation with his tribe. And even though the entire rest of his nation basically got confused and depressed and fell apart, Quanah had this bizarre philosophy of "better make the best of a bad situation", learned how to play American politics, made himself rich, and then spent the rest of his life doing awesome stuff like founding the peyote movement among Native Americans, traveling the country, going hunting with President Roosevelt, and last but definitely not least, marrying seven wives.

      Overall I liked this book. It made a not-very-good decision to meander back and forth around history instead of going in an easy-to-follow straight line, but I forgive it. It was sort of romantic, alternately sensationalizing the Comanches as murderous psychopaths and idealizing them as noble and free, but sometimes the world really is romantic, and you don't get extra points for trying to make it sound boring. And it shed light on a part of history that was apparently pretty important for the American West and about which I had previously been entirely unaware.
      linkReply

      Comments:
      [User Picture]From: snysmymrik
      2012-11-13 08:11 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      >>>They just rode around on horses hunting buffalo and starting wars. But they were really, really good at it.

      Genghis Khan would have been so proud...
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: jordan179
      2012-11-13 08:43 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      I have long wondered whether civilization was a mistake. If it was, it is not an easy mistake to avoid. The stubborn persistence of the Comanches aside, once civilized people with technology and professional armies start competing with less civilized people, the results are always going to be lopsided in civilization's favor. We might be at the bottom of a prisoner's dilemma, the descendants of people who defected from a happy equilibrium of hunting and gathering in order to gain a slight numerical and military advantage over their foes, only to end up with everyone large, well-armed, and miserable.

      Mobility. We are on a path which will enable Mankind to spread throughout the Universe. Noble savages will never spread beyond a single planet, and their race is doomed to die when something interrupts its inhabitability.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: snysmymrik
      2012-11-13 12:13 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      >>>Noble savages will never spread beyond a single planet, and their race is doomed to die when something interrupts its inhabitability.

      EVERYONE is doomed to die when something interrupts inhabitability of the place they inhibit. 8-)
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Expand)
      (no subject) - jordan179 Expand
      From: (Anonymous)
      2012-11-13 09:53 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      There's still many small groups of Indians in Oklahoma, none of which live on reservations. The eastern half of the state (which was actually Indian Territory, and not Land Run land given to white settlers like that west of Oklahoma City) is roughly 10% Native, and I would estimate at least 25% claim some Native heritage, whether or not it's technically true (just look at Oklahoman Elizabeth Warren). The strong connection to Native American culture is something that always attracted me to that part of the country -- there's so many ancient cultures represented in such a small area.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: squid314
      2012-11-13 03:37 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      If I understand the situation there correctly, the Indians were placed on reservations in Oklahoma, then the reservations were dissolved because white people wanted to move into Oklahoma and the Indians were "compensated" by being given private property rights to whatever small parcels of land they already lived on.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: cartesiandaemon
      2012-11-13 10:03 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      Happy Lifestyle

      My uninformed impression is that you don't need to do specifically hunter-gatherer things to be happy, but people tend to be happy if they have a similar sort of mix of:

      - lots of leisure time
      - lots of exercise
      - a few hours necessary work a day

      so platonic forms are probably a good guide to a good lifestyle, but not the One True Way.

      Civilization a mistake

      There definitely seems to be a trade-off here. It seems like hunter-gatherer lifestyle is day-to-day much much heathier and enjoyable than agrarian lifestyle, although agrarian is necessary if you have a lot more people, or a drought.

      Similarly, it may have taken us 10,000 years to get here, but having medicine for childbirth and infectious diseases, etc, is a definite plus. Hunter-gatherers may be less prone to disease than city dwellers, and generally healthier, but having magic "make bacterial diseases go away" drugs is a pretty sweet upgrade.

      Another way of looking at the European invasion of America (which I don't endorse, but is an interesting reversal) is like the occupy movement: why should the native Americans with 100s of acres each enjoying a life of leisure not have to subsidise the impoverished Europeans who often had no land and no money?

      Although the native Americans could retort "we didn't massively overbreed, why should we share the burden?"

      And the Europeans would reply "neither did we, our parents did!"

      And the native Americans would say "so you're not going to massively overbreed now, right?"

      And the Europeans would say "um..."

      So, in balance, I'm not sure. Is it better to have a healthy lifestyle of leisure? Or to have a massively increased resistance to dying in infancy and childbirth, or in famines or plagues?
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: naath
      2012-11-13 11:39 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      Happy lifestyle; my instinct is that "most people able to understand most things that are present in life" is a happy-causing thing. If your life is simple then it is quite easy for a curious individual to gain a reasonable working grasp of all aspects of it, maybe not to be a total expert society-renowned do-er of each thing but a competent person.

      But in today's Britain it's really not possible for any one person to be even vaguely useful at *everything*.

      Specialisation makes civilization work; but maybe it makes us unhappy when we do it.

      However I am certainly all for medicine.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
      (no subject) - tremensdelirium Expand
      (no subject) - marycatelli Expand
      (no subject) - squid314 Expand
      [User Picture]From: celandine13
      2012-11-13 01:21 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      You're the second person whom I really respect who told me to read that book. I think I really should.

      I've given some thought to the "hunter-gatherer lifestyles really are better" thing. First of all, I don't buy the argument that "our brains evolved for this, so it must be more satisfying" because humans have evolved significantly since the Paleolithic. Lactose tolerance is a *recent* invention. You think our brains haven't been changing too?

      On the other hand, it *is* true that you need lots of pressure (and sometimes cruel abuse) to get nomads to settle, or hunters to farm, or artisans to behave like industrial factory workers. (The history of the Gypsies in Eastern Europe under Communism is a lot like the history of the Native Americans here -- forcing nomads to live in housing projects creates crime and alcoholism and unspeakable misery.) I have some hope for the idea of creating modern lifestyles that are more hunter-gatherer-like.

      I know people who live various kinds of gypsy existences, usually heavily technology-aided but sometimes not. There's the "bartender in the Australian outback" path like Louie, there's the "consultant wandering with lute & sword" thing that Venkat Rao does, there's Kevin and his supplement business...the world is much bigger than you imagine. I'm not up for that life, I don't think, but the people who go that way *do* seem "alive" in the way you mean. And they don't even have to gang-rape their enemies!

      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: marycatelli
      2012-11-13 01:54 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      Then how did settlement start when they were the first ones and no one was there to pressure them?
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Expand)
      (no subject) - celandine13 Expand
      (no subject) - Emanuel Rylke Expand
      (no subject) - squid314 Expand
      (no subject) - randallsquared Expand
      (no subject) - marycatelli Expand
      (no subject) - oscredwin Expand
      [User Picture]From: vinaigrettegirl
      2012-11-13 01:27 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      Having grown up with this it is lovely to read your enthusiastic and involved thoughts...

      One thing about indigenous life from that place and time that struck me from childhood was that the Comanches (and other migrating hunting cultures: the Pawnee, the Apaches, and the Sioux) were patrilinear; the Dine, or Navajo, were and remain matrilinear and nonmigrant, and arguably have retained more of their culture, long-term. They too had a form of empire; and although the Comanche were indeed dominant in their region they had both outright war, and skirmishes, with the Sioux, and both Pawnee and Apaches. There's a lot of good reading ahead!
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: squid314
      2012-11-13 03:55 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      The fact that the Navajo got an absolutely huge (comparatively) reservation that wasn't broken up later probably was also helpful, but I don't really know enough about them to have a strong opinion.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: Emanuel Rylke
      2012-11-13 01:30 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      So in summary Comanches were:
      Not living in a very hierarchical society.
      Very skilled at what they did - implying individuals were allowed lots of time to hone their skills.
      Not practicing a religion that made them afraid of divine punishment.
      Not monogamous.

      I read the blogs of a few people whose lifestyle also could be described like that. They seem able to maintain (maybe even advance) civilization.

      So i would say that from "people like to live like Comanches" doesn't necessarily follow "civilization is wrong".

      ps:
      writing "Non monogamous" was a rhetorical trick. The Comanches were polygynous, and the people whose blogs i read are polyamorous.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: marycatelli
      2012-11-15 01:46 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      Actually the lack of hierarchy is one of the unhappy-making things. Humans are still primates enough to want it, and the way hunters and gatherers stay egalitarian is relentless abuse of anyone who is doing better than others, to prevent its accruing as status.

      Well, for the victim. I bet the other member enjoy letting their envy run free.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: marycatelli
      2012-11-13 01:47 pm (UTC)

      Gonick

      (Link)

      I have to point out that Gonick is not very accurate. I mean, as in his synopsis of Augustine's Confessions has five lies in it.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: marycatelli
      2012-11-13 01:51 pm (UTC)

      Re: Gonick

      (Link)

      That's in four panels, BTW.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
      Re: Gonick - squid314 Expand
      Re: Gonick - marycatelli Expand
      [User Picture]From: marycatelli
      2012-11-13 01:50 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      One of my hopes for the future is that someone figures out how to combine the aspects of hunter-gatherer life that seem so important for proper human development with some of the advances we've had since then, like medicine and technology and science and not torture-killing people and having some idea what's going on.

      Feser probably thinks that unlike the squirrel, man is fallen and does not find his nature natural and spontaneous.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: marycatelli
      2012-11-13 02:20 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      I point out that contrary to popular belief, hunters and gatherers -- all of them -- are much more violent than civilized people. Much. The !Kung of the Kalahari, when investigated, had a murder rate higher than that of New York City at its absolute worse.

      The torture-killing of people is a lot easier than you might think.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Expand)
      (no subject) - jordan179 Expand
      (no subject) - (Anonymous) Expand
      (no subject) - marycatelli Expand
      (no subject) - squid314 Expand
      (no subject) - marycatelli Expand
      [User Picture]From: cousin_it
      2012-11-13 02:09 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      Here's a nice post about nomads vs settlers in programming.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: marycatelli
      2012-11-13 03:05 pm (UTC)

      (Link)


      White people being captured and raised by Comanches. The captives being recaptured years later and taken back into normal white society. Indians being defeated and settled on reservations and taught to adopt white lifestyles. And throughout the book's description of these events, there was one constant:

      All of the white people who joined Indian tribes loved it and refused to go back to white civilization.


      The whites had Stockholm Syndrome and the Indians didn't?
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: squid314
      2012-11-13 03:56 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      Doesn't take into account voluntary defections to the Indians; also, why would this be?
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread) (Expand)
      (no subject) - marycatelli Expand
      (no subject) - katsaris Expand
      (no subject) - marycatelli Expand
      (no subject) - marycatelli Expand
      [User Picture]From: Randy Miller
      2012-11-13 04:27 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      Interesting post. I'll probably add the book to my wishlist. A couple things stood out for me:

      "The men had no jobs except to occasionally hunt some buffalo and if they felt courageous to go to war. The women did have jobs like cooking and preparing buffalo, but they still seemed to be getting off easy compared to the white pioneer women or, for that matter, women today. The whole culture was nomadic"
      It seems an exaggeration that in a nomadic culture the men had no jobs. They didn't train or care for the horses or other animals, or set up or break down the tents, make and maintain tools and weapons--anything analgous to the women's regular cooking chores? Your description sounds like the Commanche life was great, except for the murder-rape and oppression of women.

      Second, I find your thoughts on pre-modern life vs civilization interesting. I'm growing increasingly anti-modern of a few topics, although different ones I suspect than you. Bu the reason unciviilized folks appear more impressive (aside from diet) is that they have to be broadly competant in a number of areas to survive. The settlers had to do a few things very well; even moreso now with all the more specialization.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: zarzuelazen
      2012-11-13 06:08 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      This is the Hanson dichotomy of farmers versus foragers again is it not?

      There's probably good reasons why the hunter-gatherer lifestyle dies out, I think the explanation I read somewhere is that its just not sustainable for large populations, only small numbers of people could live that way.

      But yes, psychologically, I think many people would be much happier as foragers rather than farmers, so Singularity will hopefully see the 'revenge of the foragers' and a return to some of the more attractive aspects of that type of social organization (but updated to a new high-tech form).

      In the modern world, tropes such as hacker/pick-up artist/lifestyle designer/nomad/traveller indicate new moves in this direction perhaps?

      Frankly, the need to have to remain in a fixed place to make money (the 9-5 'farmer' grind) is huge pain in the backside, and sure ain't making people happy.

      I recently struck a big spectacular lottery jackpot and that resulted in my miserable 'farmer' existence in New Zealand coming to a swift end. So I've become the 'forager' I was meant to be now, and thus I travel the world.

      Currently in Oxford, England right now, an incredibly charming and wonderful place. The reach of a lottery winner extends far and wide ;) Only in perpetual travel and exploration can the forager feel truly alive.



      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: sunch
      2012-11-13 09:33 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      I remember reading about Russian military men who fought in Chechnya (in recent wars, this century) and got home not being able to live normal lives and wanting to go back to war (and going) again and again. Everything is much more simple and true there, they said, and you feel alive.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: vinaigrettegirl
      2012-11-13 10:06 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      Curious: where would you place pastoralist nomads on regular migration routes, augmented with seasonal short-term cultivation and hunting/gathering, along this dipole?
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: squid314
      2012-11-14 05:39 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      Not sure.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
      From: nomophilos
      2012-11-13 10:54 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      I feel the same way about history: the version I learnt in school was much too linear and simplified (also, Yay Cartoon History of the Universe! Though I was interested in history before reading that)

      (French and British union? What the eff?)

      Maybe Ems will feel about us the way you feel about Comanches ... meatlings will protest they want to leave the pods, and eventually the central conglomerate will relax and say to try it. They leave the pods and...nothing. Their landmarks have all corroded. The streets they once walked are covered with cables and antennas and solar pannels. The plants they once ate only grow in vats. So they slink back to the pods in despair and stay there until they die.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: squid314
      2012-11-14 05:40 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franco-British_Union

      Yes, I agree that ems are a good metaphor, and I'm much less accepting of that possible future than Robin is.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
      From: (Anonymous)
      2012-11-14 12:54 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      Civilization isn't good at making people happy. Civilization is good at spreading civilization. There's a significant difference.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: torekp
      2012-11-16 01:13 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      Scott put it better:
      We might be at the bottom of a prisoner's dilemma, the descendants of people who defected from a happy equilibrium of hunting and gathering in order to gain a slight numerical and military advantage over their foes

      If you ignore the implication that the military advantages of farming were deliberately sought, it's an impressive hypothesis. Whether a competitive advantage is intended or not, evolution will spread it - but that may or may not be to the happiness advantage of anyone involved.
      (Reply) (Parent) (Thread)
      From: (Anonymous)
      2012-11-14 06:54 pm (UTC)

      Join my pirate crew

      (Link)

      Are you sick of eating toothpaste? Do you want to be the Best squirrel you can be?

      Though you Yvain certainly could be a doctor or perhaps a financier, my boy have you considered a more challenging career? http://youtu.be/j1l7N-WLa3Q

      Arrrgghh join me pirate crew! http://lesswrong.com/lw/f65/constructing_fictional_eugenics_lw_edition/7pne

      We aim for efficient charity too.

      -Konkvistador

      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: drethelin
      2012-11-14 07:02 pm (UTC)

      (Link)

      So all of these accounts seem REALLY male-centric, and they conform to a lot of masculine stereotypes/traditions. Did kidnapped women feel happier? You say commanche women had it easier than pioneer women, but there don't seem to be an reports from their point of view compared to men saying they had it easy. Do you think trading less workload for increased chance of rape and kidnapping is a good deal?

      Also: Survivor effects. The men who get kidnapped and survive in Commanche society, and the men who survive in commanche society but then get kidnapped seem FAR more likely to be the kind of men for whom that life is happy than the kind of men who would be happier passively sitting at home and reading books or engaging in pleasant conversation instead of going out raping and pillaging.
      (Reply) (Thread)
      [User Picture]From: multiheaded
      2012-11-15 10:50 am (UTC)

      (Link)

      I've read this review while under the influence of an imagination-expanding substance, and damn, Yvain... Just... duuuude, WOW.

      Now I better go out jogging, at least - I gotta feel the wind in my face! And then it's back to delicious toothpaste...

      P.S. I realize that this is a stereotypical low-quality comment, sorry 'bout that.
      (Reply) (Thread)

      He interrupted her. Close at hand is a stable where two beautiful ponies are kept. They are snowy white, and are consecrated to the goddess Ku-wanon, the deity of mercy, who is the presiding genius of the temple. They are in the care of a young girl, and it is considered a pious duty to feed them. Pease and beans are for sale outside, and many devotees contribute a few cash for the benefit of the sacred animals. If the poor beasts should eat a quarter of what is offered to them, or, rather, of what is paid for, they would soon die of overfeeding. It is shrewdly suspected that the grain is sold many times over, in consequence of a collusion between the dealers and the keeper of the horses. At all events, the health of the animals is regarded, and it would never do to give them all that is presented. On their return from the garden they stopped at a place where eggs are hatched by artificial heat. They are placed over brick ovens or furnaces, where a gentle heat is kept up, and a man is constantly on watch to see that the fire neither burns too rapidly nor too slowly. A great heat would kill the vitality of the egg by baking it, while if the temperature falls below a certain point, the hatching process does not go on. When the little chicks appear, they are placed under the care of an artificial mother, which consists of a bed of soft down and feathers, with a cover three or four inches above it. This cover has strips of down hanging from it, and touching the bed below, and the chickens nestle there quite safe from outside cold. The Chinese have practised this artificial hatching and rearing for thousands of years, and relieved the hens of a great deal of the monotony of life. He would not have it in the scabbard, and when I laid it naked in his hand he kissed the hilt. Charlotte sent Gholson for Ned Ferry. Glancing from the window, I noticed that for some better convenience our scouts had left the grove, and the prisoners had been marched in and huddled close to the veranda-steps, under their heavy marching-guard of Louisianians. One of the blue-coats called up to me softly: "Dying--really?" He turned to his fellows--"Boys, Captain's dying." Assuming an air of having forgotten all about Dick¡¯s rhyme, he went to his place in the seat behind Jeff and the instant his safety belt was snapped Jeff signaled to a farmer who had come over to investigate and satisfy himself that the airplane had legitimate business there; the farmer kicked the stones used as chocks from under the landing tires and Jeff opened up the throttle. ¡°Yes,¡± Dick supplemented Larry¡¯s new point. ¡°Another thing, Sandy, that doesn¡¯t explain why he¡¯d take three boys and fly a ship he could never use on water¡ªwith an amphibian right here.¡± Should you leave me too, O my faithless ladie? And years of remorse and despair been your fate, That night was a purging. From thenceforward Reuben was to press on straight to his goal, with no more slackenings or diversions. "Is that you, Robin?" said a soft voice; and a female face was seen peeping half way down the stairs. HoMElãñÔóÂÜÀ­³ó ENTER NUMBET 0016hilliot.org.cn
      www.imersia.net.cn
      www.gfuboi.com.cn
      www.fxowlh.com.cn
      www.kschain.com.cn
      hjterj.com.cn
      qsbk.net.cn
      www.shenyanyi.com.cn
      opnyen.com.cn
      nmgqzgwy.org.cn
      插你肥穴 制服丝袜旗袍涶乱的小电影 日本兽王无码全集 朋友们开撸吧欧美图片 � 人兽性交影片 维族人黄色片 日本女孩小嫩穴摄影 三八人体图片基地 美国 女人体图片欣赏 女人洞人体艺术 强奸做爱短片小说 父媳乱来 成人乱伦小说狠狠 91自拍电影网 我的美艳岳母小说撸二哥 谁有仓井空的电影 堂成人免费视屏 最大 拾贰月重磅巨献高清私拍安徽合肥随妻5p av女优超市 tube兽人 人体少女成人艺术 丝袜淫娃女空姐 欧美熟妇刚交图 新号百度云怎么看片 李忠瑞影音先锋下载 日本女人超黄色人体 男女明星日逼图片 sss性交图片 超级玛丽兄弟电影三级片 gaoqingtoupaiyiyuannvce 擢撸少妇色图 美女逼图欣赏 他州色图 麻岛美几 jav365熟女俱乐部 夜夜摸东京热 7788dcom 亚洲成人电台 美女自己玩射了18p 亚洲美女掰鲍图 色妹妹影视下载 丝袜美女露阴门图片 小说 吃咪咪 黄色电影全草免费 爱爱医学网 干骚逼 射进肉洞 迅雷长片狠狠撸 大胆97人体 WWW_PS31_INFO 胖妹子和瘦妹子做爱有什么不同 WWW_ZARA_COM 明星18avday 乳交 乱伦 鸡巴 女儿的嫩洞逼 人妖变装图片 忧忧人体艺术导航 日韩考屄视频 粗鸡巴日骚屄 快播52淫 超诱惑骚妇奶子图片 黑巨屌插烂插扯阴道 四季美农贸城 招商银行客户端下载 情债电视剧 时空猎人电脑版下载 黑男白女种子 谁有亚洲美图网站2014 黑丝电影有哪些 苍井空的逼放大图 鼘掠牒趯? 就要搞妹妹 撸撸网王老撸 大鸡巴肏死小骚屄了 狼友迷奸自拍视频 韩国a片观看 徐莹性爱视频ed2k 女人和畜生做爱的小说 日本爽片种子 极品淫荡骚货 操逼有害不可大力日比 大香蕉很狠撸 喜欢日肥女人 小说享受泰国浴 亚洲成人10p 草小少妇屁股 李宗瑞100级 少女的阴蒂儿阴道 六九av影院 林心如两腿分开 汤芳最大胆全裸体清晰图 哪个网可看黄色图片 狂插妹妹15p 影音先锋黑人幼幼 WWW_211VV_COM av怎么看不了 给德国处女开包 夜色贵族成人小说区时间 美女爱骚逼 爱爱小说乱伦 欧美女人全裸照片 幼幼被3p 大吊黑逼 粉色骚逼 我插过的女人 日本熟女友田真希电影影音先锋播放 草裙操比 我要肏贾玲 黄色电影影音 小姐的阴道夹的我好爽 ww66avav 国语影视先锋 手机皇色视频网站大全 WWW59QRCOM 五月亚州婷婷炸天撸 张筱雨被男人插人体写真 天天色偷拍自拍 欧美图库亚洲图库 欧美人妻性爱写真 成人电影网址youjizz 美国骚逼想唉操 爸爸插错洞吉吉 操少女小说网 视频偷拍逼 成人网黄色片下载 跟老婆操奶操逼 大鸡巴狠插黑黑的骚逼 骚妇粉色木耳 四房开心播播图片 雨宫琴音qv电影 久久视频在线播放观看( 去干网1月25日 亚洲性交色视频 爱爱帝国钟和区图片 粉嫩写穴 快播伦理影院全国若妻 WWW578133COM 日韩孕妇做爱 成人在线电台 大学生妹妹穴穴 快播户外乱伦电影 亚洲女色网伦理 婶婶与侄子伦理小说 苍井空秘密搜禅观 德川重男种子 佐佐木春香 qvodk8经典强奸乱伦 女鲍鱼16p 幼嫩系列在线 内射欧美 我爱插逼淫淫网 啊淫水图 奸恋图片 我和小姨在车里 骚妇淫 欧美大鸡巴照片 漂亮女优伦理电影 性爱小说97 国产呦呦100部精选集 艳女淫妇 尻逼电影 乱伦乱摸乱交配 哪个明星的逼最好看 春色校 妻子让朋友干出尿 无需播放器在线观看西山希 色喜大胆人体 国产自拍偷拍在线播放若怒 成人孕妇性爱电影网 美女掰骚鲍www51gannet 骚逼蜜穴 家庭乱伦动漫电影 盗撮协和影视 射死你天天日百度 儿子射进来 怡春院人兽 操岳母色色网 少女嫩逼激情小说 自拍偷拍欧美美色图 家庭乱伦之巨乳妈妈 美女游戏封面相片 黑丝avi码合集 帅的男同性恋做爱的视频 本色国际 西西人体高清18岁 人体艺术舒淇艳门照 影视先先锋 亚非成人电影 究极人渣素人 weimeiqingchunccom 老头和妇女公园不雅视频 来点黄色的videombaiducom 色漫画之丝袜少妇 第一放映室伦理欧美 狗肏人网 农村tongjian 能直接在线观看图片的网站 操你妹手机电影 妇色小说 国产抽插开档黑丝女友 色狠窝 朋友的处女女友m06xscom 伦全集狠狠射 tt老婆 yingqi 制服超短裙番号迅雷下载 变态图区精品 谷露英语 日本一级毛片magnet 徐东东丝袜图片 AV区亚洲AV欧美AVwww9966acomwwwc5508comwwwshcateringcom 女性全裸近照无遮挡物 短篇剧情网站 亚洲无码女教师撸 午夜A片播 大尺度强暴性爱 色网站色网站 久草在线被监禁了的身体玩具 欧洲学妹性交视频 当着外人的面插入下载 日本美女性交24p图片 renyudongwuxingjiao capron马蓉出轨 明星合成欧美色色欧美性爱区欧美骚妇欧美成人色图欧美大奶欧美大胆人体 真人做色性动态图片 八戒街拍裙底 春药潮吹痉挛视频 思思热资源站 久草在线视频7mwwwgsobc1024cnmyiwancom 比基尼淫 花井美纱RKI252磁力链接 少妇熟女搞逼 裸体女奴小说 两性故事淫荡家庭 日韩少妇人妻系列 人妻的禁忌 riyelu国语 耽美骚货出水 17岁少女跪嫁68岁老汉 性交口交天天撸 制服丝袜1页日日摸 b3jjj 哥哥综合影院雅蠛蝶五次郎 偷拍自偷人妻自慰 西方人与狗性交片 艳照门视频华为网盘 偷拍性生活祝频 WWW_621YY_COM 欧美女生阴道艺术 sek115苞米地 影音先锋a9电影 亚洲成人动漫av 97成人在线乐子 2015Tv丶C0M 星河大帝同人小说 夜插 日本熟女性爱偷拍xjo530tumblrcom 美女b比图片 小泽玛利亚与人妖图片 成人大胆诱惑人体艺术图片 大色se片 偷拍自拍内衣12p 少女小山雀69Xx wwwfafa98om 美国发布站2K3HH wwww336bbbcom 成人做爱有哪些影院 亚洲777www69rhcom 尼姑云影视 制服丝袜图片网站 vr美腿丝袜 天天操日日艹 破处番号 偷拍影音先锋电影网 意淫强奸人妻女友 AV电影百度云 ggggbb 北原多香子全集种子 97资源www688bxcom 正在播放87午夜孕妇 无码一级黄视频 强奸乱伦 哥哥干 色狗狗综合视频网站 先锋影音成人动 日本av百人群Pav 成人3d卡通动漫在线 wwwjjzzocom 成人性全免费视频 网55eekcom 色和尚被偷拍的女主播 微信可以处理违章吗 a图片大全 欧美成人裸体网 欧美家庭伦理片资源下载mp4 妓女av网 欧美图片激情小说 1333ccc ee214magnet 最新日本av在线视频 姐姐爱爱集 狠狠爱五色天大香蕉 哈尔滨狼友 乱伦日韩欧美制服手机在线 wwwavsj 64sm 偷偷拍自拍15p 国产偷拍厕所在线视频 强奸军人母亲 日本有个是主播做爱的片子吗 亚洲第一在线黄色网站 东方东方伊甸园苍井空 蜜桃丁香 www2Csex872com 231avav 爱吧综合 黄色网站空姐被强奸下载 啊扣你的小穴 五月天激情网址 大香蕉精品520 色中色AV在线视频哥哥干 奇米成人影视色和尚、色尼姑 新西兰成人片 500av大香蕉 黄色1级片 看欧美AV剧情片的网站 性插网页 av大b视频 撸波波映院 人妖当着妈妈和爸爸 v2视频网站 千百撸综合 教室调教老师 另类小说专区在线 av在线总站 www725bb 摩擦影院5566 女人的穴是万能的 乱伦性交激情小说 亚洲1AV 高清av1080在线 大香蕉波波在线视频 淫汁Y 清纯唯美哥哥撸 sex888欧美片 依依社区影院撸lu射 995hao m3344tt 草民盒子 西西人体偷拍另类 狠狠操骚b 亚洲偷拍自拍最新网站 制服丝袜av天天 3d黄片 kk999pw下载 WWWavtb789com 男同志免费影片 琪琪电影网李宗瑞 色在线奶奶 579路com wwwyoujizzcom美女 有没有幼女的视频网站 欧美私处艳照 亚洲图片欧美图片日本av成人有声 国产小黄片网站 搜索www123456789 撸一撸美女人体 操小屄还玩老屄 淫淫色色色色 深爱萝莉 花样困绑虏待女人方法 很哈图热图 wwwcom84 wwwsyy31con 草莓社区2016新地址 国产av91自拍 鸡鸡和光屁股 夜一夜撸一撸 91luCOM 最新乱伦比较黄的肉文 嫩妹妹色妹妹干妹妹 av英语老师 美女合集早时候的图片 韩国浴池在线播放 奶大性爱基地 L三级片 美女的逼怡院 影音先锋偷看媳妇中文 91qq1com wweuucom 美国伦理在线 狼窝激情影院影音先锋 韩国邪恶动做片mp4 古代激情17P 男操男小说 干哥哥插妹妹逼 成人激情12P 好色视频超碰碰碰 yaolu导航最新地址 同性恋舔我小穴 在线视频主播AV 手机看片www555com 整部的黄色小说 男人强奸女人操逼的视屏 色黑木耳穴 经典乱伦性爱故事 色四图吧 广濑奈央美 无码 国产成人在线视频网站 女知青风流小说 高兴为什么呢哪俩唱的 女人wumaoyingbutu 儿子与母亲的乱伦性爱故事情节 爽图在哪里看 屄 亚洲 hongkongav 乱伦熟女做爱视频 欧美破处视频区 爆插长腿黑丝妹50p 后宫社区最新最新地址 最新肥胖人体艺术摄影 淋浴做爱av 李宗瑞性侵录像网址 热香屄 女主播艳门照 车上逼逼图 为什么我喜欢让情人操我 性爱av哪里能看 影视先锋伦理电影 国内老女人av在线视频 欧美黄色网站视频第一页 美女乱论小说 日本人操b图片 神木轮奸犯王伟 与狗爱爱网聊视频 嫩乳妹妹人体艺术 1238090com 郭富城早期经典视频 女忧快播影音先锋 色色偶性爱自拍 肏嫩屄舔雪白屁股插进去 叶欣桐图片库 国产视频操胖老奶奶10306 激情爱爱1qq号是多少 酒色视频网最新网址 成人电影微信群 苍井空的电影名字 想几个男人操逼逼 在酒吧把泥酔巨乳女带回家狂插先锋影音 色mm激情万种 美女人体馒头 明星华为网盘 老妈与我乱伦 亚洲色图 女大学生性爱 毛色黄片网站 非洲美女陆逼网战 偷拍亞洲路上幼小情侶做愛相片圖? 女人白虎屄 bb性爱视频 大鸡吧干衅 日本成人强奸乱伦电影 在哪能找艳照门 欧美嫂子qvod 我喜欢大奶女人 亚洲爱色套图 遥子里被操的图片 色爱在线视频 36周了感cnbb头己下了 不举总裁的盗种妻 美国最年轻的总统 wendao 甚至导致严重的肌腱炎。建议不要长时间发短信, 梦幻西游69群p 武器战士输出手法 韩国人体艺术新闻 关于怡红院的网名 少女18艺术图片 色沟影院 女人杂交视频 大鸡巴姐姐肏骚妹妹 日本人体艺1 上原结衣的片去哪个网站找 makeloveveido 91快播电影国外处女 人体图全女 女子健美漏屄图片 美足自慰 畸形逼 吉泽明步orrent 人妻性爱色图影音先锋 女艺术图 qovd幼交电影 韩国女明星被潜规则爱爱电影 快播免费成人禁片 日本强奸资源 熟女尿射口 鑹叉儏缃戠珯链夎皝鐭ラ亾 午夜性交图片 走光露屄毛的女人 操妹妹逼 撸撸涩涩图片 惩罚骚货熟女 小岳母的淫水 狠狠干激情 人体艺术女同性恋视频 暴操成都艺校妹妹 我爱和妈妈和妹妹乱伦小说 成人极品小说合集 人体射精艺术图30p 三级片3级片四级片视频 美女的下部肉肉图 和女仆干真爽电影 在线视频录像 WWWAAACOMYAZHO 奇艺人体艺术 人狗性交私处照 插妹妹自拍偷拍 RE789COM 鲁鲁射射 深爱激情网免费视频播放 清纯唯美中文 橹一橹小说阅读 骚女嫂子 幼女小说长篇 屄都什么样 咪咪网王老撸 手机浏览器看不了在线视频 婶婶在果园里把我了 少妇熟女乱伦强奸 粉红亚洲妹偷拍自拍 WWWWWNNVCOM 国产av大片 一圾片2013推存 日本少妇伦理小说 黄昏去操逼俄罗斯 玉女情挑吉吉音影 色四月婷婷网五月天肉文 亚州成人大奶综合电影 老江吃嫩草20 亚洲怡红院首页 日本城人电 色哥百度 WWWGAN521COM 激情网站wwwhuangsedianyingnet 强暴乱伦爱爱 httwww8888tpcom 台湾无码A片欲火焚身 婷婷五月亚洲Avwww317avcom wwwAVKUTV 本站只适合18岁以上观看 tom色播网 免费成人网绐 www111eecom四虎影裤成人精品 小苍奈奈网站 妻子地铁失身 印度毛片ed2k 儿子插完妈妈插妹妹 xingjiaoluanai WWWWEIBOCOM 淫姐姐骗了弟弟操她逼 小鲜肉操熟女 老色哥奇米影视26uuu 插进妈妈的肥逼 网友自拍偷偷师爷 成人动漫亚洲色图意淫强奸亚洲色图意淫强奸 好骚色色re 不小心小孩插大人影音先锋 韩国少女掰屄图 wwwqylsp1 YY6080PAPAPA 中国空姐干逼视频 观看美女自慰直播的网址 2017搜片神器是那个 强奸色女网 日韩人与兽爱爱 母淫网姐姐 亚洲娃娃 猛操骚货痴女护士文 亚洲大奶老女人 韩国电影熟女的欲望 偷窥厕所漫画 儿媳妇与公公三级片电影 好看站撸啊撸撸 首页偷拍自拍朋友女友的嫩穴毛还是初长成那种 李宗瑞生殖器大吗 肥乳性爱 有声小说ok网 笑傲华夏有声小说 春色夜生活 知春色 樱井莉亚下马 樱井莉亚体重 樱井莉亚123 小泽玛利亚迅雷 大家给个h网 东京热n0570 东京热n0393rmvb 可以用快播看的黄片 哪里可以看黄片 男人为什么喜欢看黄片 川村まや 33链导航 性生活知识 一点色导航 tv69在线 插插洞插插B 多情成仁高清 群交乱伦电影 色人居成人网 性乐汇色电影 淫色网 yeye撸 撸撸侠网站 苏紫紫干露露全套 干海参怎么发 Av天堂色电影 4099y影院 3d爆乳女教师西瓜 精品ady9 52AVAV好色色屌丝 国产精品情侣av 西野翔被偷窥 怡红院福利二区 在线阿v在线澳门 人人操美丽人妻 人人摸人人揉视频在线 在线无码私人影院 午夜福利1000部757 咪咪av电影 海外啪啪啪视频 南方来信免费观看 100国产自拍 rbxjdh 七色沙耶香番号 芹泽直美诱惑女教师视频 青青草原影视免费观看 桥本美步百度云 青草碰碰 青青草人碰人视频在线观看 在线看片 欧美自拍 青青 日福利av 日本情爱电影 孕妇在家孕交视频乳交 樱濑奈bt 日本少妇cosplay母狗 日本桐冈市 日本男女抽插插福利免费动态资势 在线男人福利免费视频 爱青岛在线观看 在线小萝莉 美女主播自慰出水视频 VEC-360部长奥-八木梓 麻仓优112部全集 迷夜惨案在线观看 痴女诱惑 稀缺资源 九州av 夜趣阁AV导航 无码av种子在线观看 luoliai 黄色片大胸 日本在线强奸乱伦 淫妇骚屄欠肏视频 色午夜v 小操黄色免费管看视频网址 日本亚洲欧美无码免费视频 草莓网 日本冒死厕拍视频 大香蕉一本道富二代 天天影院色小 凹凸視頻免賛在線 女主播叫床视频在线观看 行交视屏 黄色三级轮奸高清 宅男伦理 在线观看成人影院在线 xinxin68 org 国产自拍在线更新av 蓝沢润手机免费视频 你懂百度资源 和充气娃娃爱爱视频 龙头蛇尾 童颜巨乳 色和尚在线视频久和综合色色 江川美奈子在线视频 3344df 怡夏影院成人快播 1204手机在线播放下载 4438x一全国大色 露谷试看 色女孩影视最新网址 欧美群交网 波多野结衣来广州 日本she射精视频 自拍内裤爱液 伦理片自拍短视频 爱草色综合 彩美旬果xfplay 亚洲 自拍 porn 亚洲种子av 苍井空AⅤ下载迅雷 磁力链 下载 rki435 488成年网站 52av2av av天5 极品红人cutie queen 浪货成人网 91p app 上原亚衣黄色 中文字幕av12免m看 www路AV 亚洲36D 福利视频偷拍 大香蕉在緌人妻 福利avi 福利roufan动漫在线观看 大香蕉s视频 迪厅里的黑人男女裸体交配视颖 大神夜店大山极品美女带回高级寓所阳台一直 xxx-av 20147-20148 青鱼视频2自拍 国产人妖 鬼父有无码的么 韩国三级电台在线直播 劲暴欧美 一本道 东京热 自拍 国产 无码 quanqiuzuidadechenrenwangzhan 午夜小影院。 看看福利视频92 快播AV海量资源666 亚洲激情无码视频 俄罗斯群交之影院 义母吐息在线1mm 贵妃网伦理看天长网 自拍偷拍 微信小视频 526成人网 东方影库66 韩国三级在线 成人频道 永泽真央美医院BD视频中文字幕版 miae-183星奈爱 黑人 中国情侣自拍视频对白刺激 91色老板福利电影 自拍口交网 人与兽迅雷下载 大学情侣自拍视频在线 日本一本道高精无码 护士献身捐款视频百度云 欧美incest在线视频 老牛吃嫩草大尺度爱床上视频 wwwf994 哥哥搞在线播放 爱狠狼 58国产自拍在线 120214-749在线 aapp8988视频全集 成人国产视频导航 亚洲自拍91 嫂子内射 肥佬影视 福利制服诱惑在线 啪啪免费福利网站 1さつ册のみち道电影 青欲乐视频 视频操逼i 花间小视频 magnet 日本操逼小说 九州风云4电影下载 magnet 艺校妹子全裸淫语挑逗 台湾黄色毛片 破处mp4 下载 干到一半 偷偷换人的av 欧美极品AV束缚 协和影视 julia www11peng 色女香蕉 CAO96 gvg436在线播放 露脸怒草发廊高颜值小姐 www,637Df 干莉莉 我们立足于美国法律,受美国法律 小野遥 邪恶甄姬同人 小视频啪啪来电话女的说他免费 性感漂亮的女神级嫩模黑丝情趣装大尺度私拍视频曝光这身材样貌看的让人受不 新版spanking视频 性感网袜美女床上诱惑视频 先老弟影院 涩图片97 光棍影院,色戒 美丝馆福利视频 12级高清黄片 伊人谷姐干岳电影 a4yy午夜福利网神马 爸爸你的鸡巴太大轻点我好痛 主题宾馆偷情偷拍在线 缓存淫乱视频 2O19午夜福利合集 国产黄福利自拍在线视频 欧美x片视频在线观看 性爱伦理黄色一级电影 好美呀别停舒服死了 h极品卡通 胖老外酒店嫖妓白领兼职妹子鸡巴插着逼还手指抠屁眼听呻吟小姐吃不消 靠逼福利店 成人轮奸强奸网址 国产自拍大学城美女 啪啪啪青草视频免费观看 露脸超嫩的UU7后萌萌脸美女 在沙发上被大鸡巴不停抽插 天天橾夜夜橾bAV 淫妻迅雷 80s污动漫 火色院线 538日韩精品 京香JULIA ftp 超漂亮美女AV mp4 不知火舞无翼恋母 国产小视频2015 操我求你了好痒用震动棒干我好爽飞了高潮了哦哦啊啊奥视频 操教师在线 无码小说伦理电影图片 亚洲第一福利在线视频 椎名由奈无码 中文字幕 日本av播放器 户外女主播迅雷磁力链接 强插漫画 日本无码动漫AV迅雷下载下载 人体艺术6080强插漫画 悠悠资源共享 夜色邦另类图片 ipz-746中文字幕 泷泽萝拉福利在线 caoprom超碰vr专区 色尼姑免费AV 香港古装av无码种子 贵妇的沉沦女王反转版 段艺璇 大尺度 wwwmimikkk 床戏 体验区 avav177 一本道Th 多罗罗天下之战在线观看网址 vr天海翼视频在线观看 超乳爆乳巨乳影片福利 成人刺激抽插视频 S视频在线观看 车模聂子雨 板扎福利 UD-636R mp4 VIP私人玩物粉穴 草根艳舞团 县城全裸淫荡火爆 小刀电影伦理片 久久成人国产视频精品在线 在线视频播放你懂 御姐里番acg 色爱区在线视频网站 国模依诺娃与摄影师销魂视频 黑人大香蕉在线视频 操干网 高清大尺度丝袜老师 女主播资源公众号 无内丝袜福利在线 嫩模啪啪在线观看 最新国产自拍做爱 巨乳日本人妻還欠債被 538在线精品牛牛 黑皮书第一放映室 光棍影院最新福利在线看B 婷婷午夜成人视频 全裸性交 mp4波多野结衣下载短视频 国产视频58pao 我是检察官种子 磁力链 青青在线葡京视频 2018国产欧美在线va 日本啪啪视频无马赛克视频网站 欧美同性视频vibes 韩宝贝在线播放 韩国美女性解放与性交视频 国产主播特大阳具插入视频 韩国美女大胆生殖器23p 不堪欺辱的小林初花磁力链 国内在线自拍 国外另类大尺度福利网站 国产视频偷拍a在线观看 操逼视步 国产自拍丝袜 被强行占有第一次视频磁力 爆乳寡妇替欠债亡夫用身体肉偿 1曰本巨乳清木视频 有部小说男主在一个部门拿手机录下他上司和女员工做爱又拿录象和女员工做爱是 luoli写真 国产福利最新 蓝导航全福利导航 偷拍视频视频在线观看 刘可颖视频在线播放 美女翘臀肛交视频 亚洲香蕉视频在线播天堂网房 夜射猫精品av自拍在线 日本视频欧美一本道 国产大胸美女链接 mp4 2淫色人妻乱伦电影 上原亚衣 喷水无码在线 ibw518z ftp wwwjingziwou8 吉永尤利娅磁力 美女裸体直播迅雷下载 亚州无码中文字幕 www锛巃aakkk88锛巆n t午夜电影 东京热菜菜绪爱在线观看 rctd 3838pao,com 图激情五月婷婷丁香 欧美性爱大片黄 人妻众大香蕉视频在线播放了 女神一级毛片 www在线观看视频av草樱 luo女aa 射野之王在线 美国guolunlipianhuangshan 乱伦在线播放 裸聊直播在线免费观看 色老爹在线影院 鲁管电影 小视频 美国少妇与水电工 激情亚洲自拍偷拍 激情影院的祼体照片 精品小旅馆偷拍貌似很饥渴大白天偷情男女进来就迫不及待开草玩的姿势还不少 吉林市sm群 奸尸视频 magnet 拳交高清无码视频 街拍厕所 mp4 情侣激情爱爱自拍视频 极度高潮yyxf视频 AAAA快播 91金龙鱼最新-气质漂亮的良家少妇苏小小偷偷兼职做楼凤 一个更新快的色综合 av高清在线播放 偷窥自拍 清纯唯美 邱县特级黄片 男女做爱经典自拍免费 强奸乱伦影音先锋影片 免费观看爆乳家政妇 人猿泰山h版无删减mp4 小黄瓜资源站 91蟹哥 下集在线观看 黑丝袜裸体开档裤视频 欧美性交电影 黄图男在上女在一下 里番福利导航 97影院在第一页 男人透女人伦片 偷惰男女手机在线观看 手人人在线视频 阿v大香蕉性爱视频 朴妮唛在线视频全集 av在线,亚洲av 刺激影院亚洲hot 欧洲se 2艹高中女孩 男女做爱真实叫床视频 免费v片在线观看2320 哪里有a片资源 韩哥福利视频 男女抽插日p高清视频网站 バック体位で恥じらいのお尻まる出し下品な連続潮吹きjk 小島みなみ 日笔视频100部 jaⅴ颜射 友崎亚希 ftp 276ff这个网址换成什么了 大乳房美女奶头视频 一本道电影日本 自拍区偷拍亚洲最新777ap 椎名由奈 456 5388x最新更新 迷情影院一楼一凤首页 一级棒的美国j毛片 一本道日本电影天堂 91lu在线观看 普通话户外直播野战迅雷种子 东京干www12oa,me 三级黄久久免费视频 两性做爱高清写真 激情五月激情成人激情妹妹 90后人体艺术网 日本乱伦肛交灌肠颜射放尿 美女秘书加班被xo图片 xxx虐待阴茎视频 家庭乱伦都市激情校园春色自拍偷拍 丰满骚娘们视频 美女动态私处照 五月天97ss 日韩美女主播网站 欧美性爱歪歪色影网 911scc 亚洲性交30p 赶尸艳谭女角色办演着 全国成人色 美女的超短裙快播 很很累苍 xxxx333nm 美乳22p 美妞屄屄 丁香成人十次啦导航 绣由衣乱伦小说 狠狠撸操逼图片